Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts

Friday, October 24, 2008

Does action on climate change make a company sustainable?

Less than three years ago climate change was still a relatively small issue for Australian businesses and the Federal Government. At that stage only a small group of public servants were starting to develop a public discussion paper on how the State Labor governments – independent of the Federal Coalition Government – could develop a National Emissions Trading Scheme.

I remember going to one of the very first public forums on the issue. Although the general Australian business community wasn’t really awake or alert to the issue of climate change, it was obvious that a number of small businesses and consultants could see the emerging issue and wanted to be part of the solution.

Most of the consultants I met that afternoon had a background in sustainability and had personal passion to help increase the sustainability of the business sector. With all respect to those people I met, I don’t think they actually realised how action on climate change and action on sustainability were actually different things.

Action on climate change and action on sustainability are different. Fundamentally, action on climate change is a sub-set of the sustainability agenda that attempts to improve the energy efficiency of processes and reduce the negative by-products of energy consumption. Sustainability, on the other hand, attempts to increase the longevity of business and decrease the negative by-products business can have on itself, society and the environment through short-term thinking and self-interest.

Despite what many people believe, action on sustainability is not about donating to charities, volunteering, or community service. Rather, it is an attempt to create a local environment where business can continue to grow. For example, a community which does not have enough skilled people leads to a business that cannot make or sell its product. Likewise, a community without businesses does not have enough income to create a quality of life that keeps people happy, healthy and living locally.

As such, while action on climate change might reduce our carbon footprints, it does nothing to ensure we have the skilled people to make and lay our bricks, or create a situation where people want to improve their living circumstances by building new homes.

As such, despite the looming threat of higher manufacturing costs and a massive effort to reduce this, it is imperative that businesses don’t forget that they still need to engage and nurture their local communities to ensure prosperity beyond the climate change threat.

Furthermore, action on climate change will become the norm and all businesses will learn how to reduce their costs through manufacturing efficiency improvements. Conversely, action on sustainability will continue to provide a competitive edge that increase real value within the company, not just efficiency dividends.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Does greater density create greater sustainability outcomes?

To the outsider (and dare I say, for the insider), most urban planning pivots around the central assumption that greater density creates greater sustainability outcomes. Even without having any urban planning background, this assumption does intuitively make sense because with density you can minimise the amount of land cleared for housing, roads and infrastructure, and furthermore, get greater economies of scale for these and other investments, particularly public transport. Despite this intuitively making sense, after attending a number of recent forums and conferences, I get the feeling that environmental reasons and not economies of scale are driving the push for greater density.

Interestingly, however, the emphasis may be one-sided because despite the numerous planning guides limiting land release and promoting density, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) “… current homes (have) more bedrooms on average than homes ten years ago. At the same time, households are getting smaller on average with decreasing proportions of couple families with children and increasing couple only and lone person households.”

Other data doesn’t necessarily support the density assumption either. According to research conducted by the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF) in conjunction with the University of NSW, suburbs that typically have a higher density of population are actually less sustainable than those suburbs on the fringes of cities. According to Australia’s Consumption Atlas report, “…on average, single-person and small households have greater environmental impacts than larger households… (suburbs) with higher average household size also tend to have markedly lower levels of greenhouse gas pollution per capita, and smaller but still clearly lower levels of water use per capita.” ACF proposes that this is the case because wealth is higher in the inner suburbs and by extension, consumption is also higher. The primary argument of the ACF is that consumption is the key sustainability metric rather than location.

So where does the assumption that greater density produces greater sustainability outcomes emerge from? Especially if we look at some of perverse implications that urban growth boundaries have created.

Restricting land supply on the urban fringes of cities has created the situation where demand is massively outstripping supply. When combined with a prolonged period of economic growth that has provided the type of certainty individuals look for before making significant housing decisions, we now see people making decisions to have children or upgrade their homes (building their castles!). These individuals are then competing for the limited supply of land and what is interesting is that whereas once there may have been a greater sense of caution, currently we are seeing these competing individuals and families taking on greater mortgages and other debt because economic conditions are so good.

This is dangerous territory because while we may have environmental sustainability by virtue of reducing the amount of land cleared for housing, it is arguably at the cost of economic, and in particular social, sustainability outcomes. And while I agree that we should never understate the interconnected nature of the environmental system we live in, it seems that our current planning assumptions are not providing sustainable outcomes.

At the end of the day I think sustainability is a product of design because as the ACF’s research pointed out, the higher environmental impact caused by higher density suburbs is a product of consumption rather than location. If the products being consumed were designed better so that they used less electricity and water, and produced less waste, and likewise if fringes were better designed to take advantage of solar-passive design, used smarter materials (like brick!), and overall made less of an impact, then urban planning and environmental management would require a fundamentally different set of assumptions.

Because unfortunately I think that planners have occasionally lost touch with the very reason they exist, just as environmentalists have forgotten that individuals do have aspirations that are greater than their concern for the environment, and equally as business has forgotten that if there is no stable environment, then they will constantly lose money because of ‘acts of nature’ such as drought, flood, hail, etc etc.

Which brings us back to the question; does density create greater sustainability outcomes? Ironically, I think the planners had it partly right by imposing certain restrictions on developers. These restrictions, in the forms of land releases, environmental impact statements, infrastructure development etc have seen the rise of master planned estates that actually emphasis the benefits of good design. Things like recycled water, renewable power generation, tree planting, river and land regeneration, public transport, schools, and perhaps most importantly, partnerships with local businesses (to ensure jobs and services exist so the community can be self-sufficient) have become increasingly sophisticated and common.

So let’s not throw the baby out with the bath water; perhaps our best bet is to go to these developers and ask them questions about how they could do more of the good things they do, and likewise, what regulations should be in place to stop the ‘cowboys’ giving an entire industry a bad reputation! Because I think its fair assumption that leading developers would like anything which lifted their reputation in the community!

Sunday, January 20, 2008

The economics of sustainability

Interesting times; we have a US market staring down the barrel of recession and Australian commentators debating the impact this will have on Australia, while, ironically, talking about inflation and interest rate increases... go figure.

So with all this going on, it is possible that businesses might start to look more at economics than sustainability. Likewise, the new Australian Government, with all its hopes to kick start an education and renewable energy revolution, will be forced (by the Opposition at the very least) to look more closely at their spending (something the Opposition, while in Government, never had to do...).

Seriously examining spending is a good thing, but to do so now - when things are looking pretty shaky to say the least - is too late. For a long time I have argued that sustainability should be more about economics than the environment; more specifically, sustainability is about opportunity cost and long-term decision making.

If we leave aside the new Australian Government (because, let's be fair, they have not really contributed to any of the current financial or economic issues the country is currently facing), and look only at businesses, the successful businesses in the next two years will be those that made long-term decisions to save (or invest) their good fortune over the past two years, so that it could begin to deliver returns when the cycle dipped. At the end of the day, I fundamentally believe, that is sustainability.

Investment in new technology, processes or training that reduce waste, on-going costs or dependence on something else (ie the electricity grid, water supplies, or - dare I say it - people) will be critical now. Not only will it reduce costs over the coming two years when things aren't as good, but it will also better position companies to deal with the new global expectations arising from concerns about climate change.

Likewise, those companies that invested in their people, spent the extra money to refine, extend and enhance the skills of their people will also be better off during the coming two years. Now more than ever companies need smart people to develop really smart ideas about everything from the business model, to marketing and technology. Without these people, many companies may find themselves losing the good people thus creating a double negative feedback loop: productivity decreases and costs increases. And when the cycle starts to dip, these are the last two feedback loops a company wants to feel.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

A new perspective

A new year, a new perspective. For me this is even more true with the change of job. I've moved from educating the small and medium businesses on sustainability and climate change issues to educating the brick industry. Fortunately, in Australia at least, the brick industry is already quite proactive in using sustainable development practices, and even better, the industry association I have started working for - Think Brick Australia - has a huge research portfolio to demonstrate the sustainability of bricks as a building material. My job is to get that research out to builders, architects, consumers, government... the works.

Of course this does raise the question - which I have mused about often - about what would happen if we have the most sustainable businesses and buildings etc; would this make us sustainable. There is a growing body of research which says no. This, while not quite part of my job description, is what I am ever increasingly interested in.

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

why sustainability is both an envrionmental and economic issue

"Most businesses still operate according to a worldview that has not changed since the start of the industrial revolution. Then natural resources were abundant and labour was the limiting factor of production. Now there is a surplus of people whilst natural capital - natural resources and the ecological systems that provide vital life support services - is in decline. The next industrial revolution, like the first one will be a response to changing patterns of scarcity. It will create upheaval, but more importantly it will create new opportunities. Business must adjust to these new realities. Innovative businesses are already doing that"

Hawken, Lovins and Lovins, Natural Capitalism, 1999, p.19, taken from "Digital Eco-Sense: Sustainability and ICT - A New Terrain for Innovation" by Chris Ryan.

This isn't the first time my reading has taken me past Ryan's work; I like what he says and although this isn't probably his best quote, it is one that grabs me right now...

A "... new focus on innovation and sustainable development (has created) a growing conviction that ICT will provide the technological basis for a transition to a sustainable future... we are seeing the 'co-evolution' of information technology and sustainable development, where new technical capacities are appearing just at the moment in history when they will be needed to support structural change for a sustainable existence." p.10

An introduction

I find sustainability fascinating. There are so many people out there running around telling me that our whole world is on the verge of collapse and that we should be doing everything from implementing emissions trading schemes to preventing the establishment of any new coal mines to save the planet.

What I find most amazing is that while there are so many things that help people 'be green', realistically, very few people do much that actually makes a significant difference. While turning off lights and off-setting our carbon emissions may make us feel good, they don't really change the fact that the majority of the emissions are economic emissions that exist because we live such a high standard of life.

And this is where the irony exists; any action we take to tackle climate change will actually reduce our standard of living. Now I don't subscribe to the economic ruin argument of one 'great' Australian because the simple act of developing solutions will provide a new means of economic activity to replace those we lose, however, things like emissions trading schemes or stopping new coals mines at this current stage do have the impact of increasing the costs of the current lifestyles we all lead.

Perhaps this is a good thing because people are buying more things than ever (just look at our constant economic growth figures for proof) and don't look like stopping this trend just because they are now concerned about climate change. If they were really concerned, they may realise that consumption is actually as much of the problem as anything else. Accordingly, they might choose to stop buying many of the products they current enjoy, even though this probably wont change the situation much either, because there will always be someone else just around the corner to buy it instead of them... and around the corner in this case, might just be someone overseas.

And this is where it all gets tricky; if we do implement measures such as an emissions trading scheme, we actually run the risk of 'exporting' the problem. Australia has some of the highest economic, environmental and social regulations in the developed world. Any good made in Australia probably damages the environment less than some goods made elsewhere, however, if we don't manage the climate change transition appropriately, our companies may just stop making goods in Australia because it is too expensive. Instead they will go overseas, where costs are less, regulations are less, and unfortunately, environmental damage is higher...

and if that happens, how have we created a positive for the global environment by implementing tough new measures to prevent climate change in Australia? Isn't this even more ironic when we consider that our contribution to the global problem is less than 2 percent? Wouldn't it be better if we could encourage more development of goods in Australia, and complement this development by massive investment in R&D to make those goods more sustainable?