Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts

Friday, November 7, 2008

a game of cat and mouse

The Australian government is flirting with the actual policy settings it will use for emissions trading at the moment and it struck me that a game of cat and mouse, and 'double dare' is going on right now.

Looking at the challenge of decoupling economic and emissions growth, the Government has prepared its modelling for the economic impact of climate policies under four scenarios which all assume we reduce emissions by 60% of year 2000 levels by 2050. Essentially the only difference between the scenarios (especially given the marginal differences by 2050) is how quickly we start taking action. This prompted one Australian Senator to ask why we can't go further given the small differences, and it also supports my idea that dealing with climate change won't be that hard: it's just a matter of what we lose, and the increased risks we will face, between now and when we start to take action. And this is where the game of cat and mouse begins.

If reducing emissions is easy, then the urgency to do so is less. So in order to create the urgency for action, governments have to talk tough. On the other side, business does not want this urgency so it ramps up its rhetoric even further, daring the government to make decisions that will cause supposed untold damage, hoping it will take decisions that reduce the urgency.

Ultimately I think in this instance the government needs to call the bluff: despite what CEOs and other Executive's claim to know, one thing they are not very good at predicting is the next crisis (just look at the state of finances at the moment!). And the problem with the climate crisis is that we actually don't know what will eventuate if it takes hold, nor how much worse it will be if we don't take action sooner rather than later.

The other side of the modelling that I found intriguing was an implicit assumption which arguably underlines the report's conclusions and simplicity: how business will actually respond.

Given the long term nature of the modelling it is largely based on trend averages which only consider if a sector is going to grow or decline, and at what rate. The basic assumption was that a carbon price will start the decline for high energy industries relative to their ability to introduce new technology or achieve energy efficiencies.

To that end, the assumption was that high energy industries - all industries for that matter - do not want to decline and thus will make changes to prevent this. What will be interesting to observe as time plays out will be how accurate the implicit assumption is: that changes will be driven more by technology than location change. Under the technology driven assumption the economy can continue to grow without producing carbon, and therefore the report concludes that the government’s climate policies will have little negative impact on the economy in the long-term.

The dare, however, is that high-emitting industries are arguing that they will move their operations first, and take other actions second.

Personally I am not sure who will call the bluff - the government or business - but I am inclined to think that for business to call the bluff and move it operations offshore is a knee-jerk reaction that could have longer term implications as the climate issue extends across the world.

Unlike the free-trade movement or global institutions which try to create a better world, global climate change policies have the chance to actually take effect quickly and grow if the burning platform of the very climate we live in, starts to burn quicker and hotter.

And if (when?) that happens, what will be the benefit of being a company that moved its operations to avoid climate change legislation? Very quickly those extra dollars might seem quite small as the increased PR and other promotional activities add up to convince consumers that the company takes its global responsibility seriously.

And if this happens, then the cost of climate change to business will be higher still. And no one wants this.

Friday, October 24, 2008

Does action on climate change make a company sustainable?

Less than three years ago climate change was still a relatively small issue for Australian businesses and the Federal Government. At that stage only a small group of public servants were starting to develop a public discussion paper on how the State Labor governments – independent of the Federal Coalition Government – could develop a National Emissions Trading Scheme.

I remember going to one of the very first public forums on the issue. Although the general Australian business community wasn’t really awake or alert to the issue of climate change, it was obvious that a number of small businesses and consultants could see the emerging issue and wanted to be part of the solution.

Most of the consultants I met that afternoon had a background in sustainability and had personal passion to help increase the sustainability of the business sector. With all respect to those people I met, I don’t think they actually realised how action on climate change and action on sustainability were actually different things.

Action on climate change and action on sustainability are different. Fundamentally, action on climate change is a sub-set of the sustainability agenda that attempts to improve the energy efficiency of processes and reduce the negative by-products of energy consumption. Sustainability, on the other hand, attempts to increase the longevity of business and decrease the negative by-products business can have on itself, society and the environment through short-term thinking and self-interest.

Despite what many people believe, action on sustainability is not about donating to charities, volunteering, or community service. Rather, it is an attempt to create a local environment where business can continue to grow. For example, a community which does not have enough skilled people leads to a business that cannot make or sell its product. Likewise, a community without businesses does not have enough income to create a quality of life that keeps people happy, healthy and living locally.

As such, while action on climate change might reduce our carbon footprints, it does nothing to ensure we have the skilled people to make and lay our bricks, or create a situation where people want to improve their living circumstances by building new homes.

As such, despite the looming threat of higher manufacturing costs and a massive effort to reduce this, it is imperative that businesses don’t forget that they still need to engage and nurture their local communities to ensure prosperity beyond the climate change threat.

Furthermore, action on climate change will become the norm and all businesses will learn how to reduce their costs through manufacturing efficiency improvements. Conversely, action on sustainability will continue to provide a competitive edge that increase real value within the company, not just efficiency dividends.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Climate change ignorance

Last year the Australian Coal Association agreed to develop a clean coal technology fund through a 20c/tonne levy which was expected to raise over $1billion. It did that, easily, because amoung other things the price for coal actually increased by between 130-250% thus dramatically increasing the coal company profits.

Now I am not fussed that they got the extra profits or that they didn't choose to increase the size of their contribution to the clean coal technology fund; what I am surprised about, however, is the ignorance of their comment when asked by green groups why they don't contribute more...

"The fund is regarded as a great contribution for the industry and adequate for the purpose"

The ignorance of this comment is astounding for two reasons: First, "...a great contribution"?? Umm, hello, clean coal is not something they should be merely 'contributing' to... it is something they should be betting their lives on! If the renewables sector (which is supported in Australia and world-wide by the academic sector, multi-nationals and Government) get the answer first then they are out of business. It's as simple as that!

Secondly, "...adequate for the purpose"?? What purpose? The purpose of deflecting criticism or buying good PR? Maybe they think the purpose is to buy them favour with the Government so that they will be protected from actually having to do anything?

Either way, I think this demonstrates their complete lack of understanding of this issue. Irrespective of how it started, a new movement has started at both national and international levels of politics which will eventually change the way the we use energy forever. One day (and sooner than we think) we will all have solar cells on our roofs, buildings will be self-sufficient, products and materials will be designed properly and will actually break down rather than just becoming landfill.

It will be this way because although the human race is incapable of changing its wasteful ways, it is more than capable of developing goods and services that mean we don't have to think about it.

And that is where the problem with this comment lies; they still think dealing with climate change is about giving money, buy off-sets or writing sustainability reports. It's not, its about developing new and better products and services: ironically, those companies that get to this first will make a CRAP load of money doing it.

Is geosequestration really an option?

There was an article in The Age this morning talking about the potential health hazards of a carbon waste dump as compared to a nuclear waste dump. The basic argument was the author would prefer to live on a nuclear waste dump because at it could be monitored.

The carbon waste dump he was referring to was a site that was used for carbon geosequestration, and his conclusion was that all the investment in 'clean coal technology' could amount to nothing because the technology is not proven and it could create other problems over the long term. In his mind, it was better to go with nuclear.

Putting aside the issue of nuclear and if it is an alternative or not, I too have issues with carbon geosequestration. In a nut shell, my issues pivot on the reason we are seeking geosequestration as a solution: when we started producing more carbon dioxide we never thought that a natural chemical could create a problem, let alone a problem of this scale.

About a 100 years ago we realised that by burning fossil fuels (coal) we could create large amounts of energy and produce goods on a much larger and cheaper scale. In our not-so-infinite wisdom we have done this in increasing volumes ever since and pumped layer upon layer of carbon into the atmosphere. In over 100 years, it has only been in the last 30, and in particular the last 10, that we realised this created a problem. So now, to fix the problem we are proposing pumping carbon dioxide underground where C02 is also a natural chemical.

Is it just me, or does it seem like we haven't learned the lesson of why we are in this mess to begin with? How long will it be before the sequested C02 gathers in such a quantity that it starts to change the formation of rock, alters the properties of soil or does something to our table water? To be honest, I think the issue of 'leaking' is our least concern.

And in all this, I can't help but remember a Simpsons episode where Homer is Mayor and he has a problem with all the trash being generated by Springfield; in his infinite wisdom, he decides to dump all the trash in the volcano. Of course everyone loved him, it was a great idea, until there was too much trash and the volcano erupted, spitting all the trash back onto Springfield...

How long do we really think it will it be before our 'great idea' becomes another problem and Mother Nature spews our trash back at us?

Sunday, January 20, 2008

The economics of sustainability

Interesting times; we have a US market staring down the barrel of recession and Australian commentators debating the impact this will have on Australia, while, ironically, talking about inflation and interest rate increases... go figure.

So with all this going on, it is possible that businesses might start to look more at economics than sustainability. Likewise, the new Australian Government, with all its hopes to kick start an education and renewable energy revolution, will be forced (by the Opposition at the very least) to look more closely at their spending (something the Opposition, while in Government, never had to do...).

Seriously examining spending is a good thing, but to do so now - when things are looking pretty shaky to say the least - is too late. For a long time I have argued that sustainability should be more about economics than the environment; more specifically, sustainability is about opportunity cost and long-term decision making.

If we leave aside the new Australian Government (because, let's be fair, they have not really contributed to any of the current financial or economic issues the country is currently facing), and look only at businesses, the successful businesses in the next two years will be those that made long-term decisions to save (or invest) their good fortune over the past two years, so that it could begin to deliver returns when the cycle dipped. At the end of the day, I fundamentally believe, that is sustainability.

Investment in new technology, processes or training that reduce waste, on-going costs or dependence on something else (ie the electricity grid, water supplies, or - dare I say it - people) will be critical now. Not only will it reduce costs over the coming two years when things aren't as good, but it will also better position companies to deal with the new global expectations arising from concerns about climate change.

Likewise, those companies that invested in their people, spent the extra money to refine, extend and enhance the skills of their people will also be better off during the coming two years. Now more than ever companies need smart people to develop really smart ideas about everything from the business model, to marketing and technology. Without these people, many companies may find themselves losing the good people thus creating a double negative feedback loop: productivity decreases and costs increases. And when the cycle starts to dip, these are the last two feedback loops a company wants to feel.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Why climate change action wont create an economic depression

Check out this YouTube clip ... This guy pretty much hits the nail on the head without even going into some of the other benefits that you get from column A which don't come from column B.

I mean if we take action to prevent climate change and the warnings all end up to be false, a global economic depression seems like a bit of a stretch given that
  • we wont be paying as much for electricity, yet we would have employed many people in the development of alternatives;
  • we'll have more and better quality water which means our agriculture industries and our ability to feed ourselves will still exit; and,
  • products will have minimal long-term presence so business will still be required to a employ people to produce the goods that we are all demanding and don't show any inclination to stop doing so.

So to extend his theory, really, there is no option but to take column A; the big question is what should column A include, and will we be able to take this action without the regulation and taxes he refers to?

Also, thanks to Sam de Brito for bringing this to my (our) attention. I enjoy Sam's blog (most of the time!) and highly commend he commentary on the movie Ferris Bueller's Day Off if you want a laugh!

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Emissions trading as a mechaism to do something about climate change.

I attended the Sydney Public Forum being held in conjunction with the Labor party initiated Garnaut Climate Change Review today and took away some very interesting points which I am not sure were the actual intention of the day. Having said that, however, the Garnaut Review has been set up to identify the real issues of climate change for Australia, so any and all points should be considered relevant to the outcome which is Professor Ross Garnaut's final report due in mid-2008.

Basically, the key message I took away from the session was the difference between carbon abatement and carbon trading. Although putting a price on carbon and setting up a market to trade carbon as a commodity should theoretically lead to carbon abatement in the economy, there is no guarantee that this will happen. Further to this, I learned that it is possible that the cost of carbon abatement (most probably defined as improving energy efficiency and investing in alternative technologies) may actually be 7 to 8 times cheaper than the cost of carbon trading!

That's huge... and it does beg the question as to why trading schemes have been identified as a key component in overcoming the climate change challenge... especially by environmentalists who would probably quake if they understood the full breadth of what markets actually create. (And please don't take that as a swing at environmentalists... I am just trying to highlight how climate change is never going to be an environmental issue again!).

To try and answer the question as to why trading has been proposed it is probably best to think about this in terms of economics 101: what is carbon? It's a negative externality of production. A trading scheme aims to place a price on carbon to internalise this cost. Why are we using a market mechanism? Because this lets the forces of demand and supply set the appropriate price of carbon. If a trading scheme wasn't used, it would (most probably) be left to government to set the price in the form of a tax.

So while a tax would be cheaper for the economy in theory (ie no need to auction permits, have bodies set up to ensure compliance, use trading houses or brokers to sell and buy carbon permits, or hire lawyers to create complicated rules regarding what constitutes a carbon off-set), if the price was set too high, there would be unnecessary burden on the economy, and conversely, if the price was set to low, there would be no real incentive to take action.

Because of this and because ultimately no one like taxes, a carbon trading scheme is now the quasi bi-partisan policy in Australia. What is interesting about this is that there is no bi-partisan support for the fundamental tool of controlling a carbon market... emission targets.

At the end of the day, regardless of what the target is, for the market to operate successfully (and many of the speakers outlined what would make the market successful today... see below*) targets are needed because they set the supply. Without the supply there can be no real demand and without demand or supply, according to economics 101, there can be no market. Furthermore without targets, business (regardless of their sector or structure) does not have the certainty to invest in carbon abatement which, when all is said and done, is the main goal of any climate change action.


*According to one speaker the requirements for a successful carbon market are
  • certainty
  • breadth and depth
  • mature and large enough to encourage speculators
  • long-term
  • not dependent on a specific exchanges (ie the transaction will occur where is makes most rational sense).

Friday, October 26, 2007

Bringing on board the skeptics

I am an advocate of climate change, but something that really annoys me is when the 'believers' totally shut down the non-believers.

I spoke at the Mosman Council launch of the clean energy for eternity chapter last night. First of all, what the guys in Bega, in particular Dr Matthew Nott, have done is fantastic. They get climate change, they are doing something about it and see it not as the end of all things, but as the start of a new era in science, technology, and, coincidentally (for their name!), clean energy!

Unfortunately, however, last night was a classic example of violating an individual's right to free speech. After all the speakers had done their thing (me included... I was talking about the impact of climate change on business), a motion was put that the Mosman area adopt a 50/50 by 2020 climate change target. Basically, that the council area would work to reduce consumption of energy by 50 % and increased the production of energy from renewable energy to 50% by 2020. Nice. But as the motion was being put, one individual asked that there be time for questions before the motion was voted on. Fair enough I say. Unfortunately for free speech and fair debate, it would seem this individual was well known to everyone there last night and is, as the Mayor put it, a "regular nuisance".

Be that as it may, not allowing him to ask one single question and speaking over the top of him every time he did attempt to ask a question doesn't help anything. In my experience talking to many businesses, many of whom are very pragmatic and not 100% sure of this thing called climate change, the one thing I have found is that you can actually find common ground. There is a way to help them see the benefit of taking action, or at least understand the concerns of those around them.

Two of the best ways to overcome most business opposition I have found are this: tell them they could save between 15-50% of their annual operating costs with Return on Investment of between six months to three years. Really, it is that simple. They save money, their business makes more money, and they are using less resources that are contributing to the climate change problem. More interestingly is that once they start these things they see quite quickly all the other things they can do and the new markets that exist for sustainable products and solutions. Before you know it, they are full-blown converts... or dare I say it, believers!

The second way is to appeal to their sense of innovation. Tell them that we use technology to power our cars and cities that is over 100 years old... for a modern, innovative economy, and more importantly for a leading-edge, innovative business, what does that say? It says pretty quickly that we aren't that modern or leading-edge or innovative. For all the new technology we have we still use these antiquated technologies. For business... that's the opportunity. Invent better technology! And you can bet your bottom dollar that if they do, they will make a fair fortune from their investment!

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

An introduction

I find sustainability fascinating. There are so many people out there running around telling me that our whole world is on the verge of collapse and that we should be doing everything from implementing emissions trading schemes to preventing the establishment of any new coal mines to save the planet.

What I find most amazing is that while there are so many things that help people 'be green', realistically, very few people do much that actually makes a significant difference. While turning off lights and off-setting our carbon emissions may make us feel good, they don't really change the fact that the majority of the emissions are economic emissions that exist because we live such a high standard of life.

And this is where the irony exists; any action we take to tackle climate change will actually reduce our standard of living. Now I don't subscribe to the economic ruin argument of one 'great' Australian because the simple act of developing solutions will provide a new means of economic activity to replace those we lose, however, things like emissions trading schemes or stopping new coals mines at this current stage do have the impact of increasing the costs of the current lifestyles we all lead.

Perhaps this is a good thing because people are buying more things than ever (just look at our constant economic growth figures for proof) and don't look like stopping this trend just because they are now concerned about climate change. If they were really concerned, they may realise that consumption is actually as much of the problem as anything else. Accordingly, they might choose to stop buying many of the products they current enjoy, even though this probably wont change the situation much either, because there will always be someone else just around the corner to buy it instead of them... and around the corner in this case, might just be someone overseas.

And this is where it all gets tricky; if we do implement measures such as an emissions trading scheme, we actually run the risk of 'exporting' the problem. Australia has some of the highest economic, environmental and social regulations in the developed world. Any good made in Australia probably damages the environment less than some goods made elsewhere, however, if we don't manage the climate change transition appropriately, our companies may just stop making goods in Australia because it is too expensive. Instead they will go overseas, where costs are less, regulations are less, and unfortunately, environmental damage is higher...

and if that happens, how have we created a positive for the global environment by implementing tough new measures to prevent climate change in Australia? Isn't this even more ironic when we consider that our contribution to the global problem is less than 2 percent? Wouldn't it be better if we could encourage more development of goods in Australia, and complement this development by massive investment in R&D to make those goods more sustainable?