Last year the Australian Coal Association agreed to develop a clean coal technology fund through a 20c/tonne levy which was expected to raise over $1billion. It did that, easily, because amoung other things the price for coal actually increased by between 130-250% thus dramatically increasing the coal company profits.
Now I am not fussed that they got the extra profits or that they didn't choose to increase the size of their contribution to the clean coal technology fund; what I am surprised about, however, is the ignorance of their comment when asked by green groups why they don't contribute more...
"The fund is regarded as a great contribution for the industry and adequate for the purpose"
The ignorance of this comment is astounding for two reasons: First, "...a great contribution"?? Umm, hello, clean coal is not something they should be merely 'contributing' to... it is something they should be betting their lives on! If the renewables sector (which is supported in Australia and world-wide by the academic sector, multi-nationals and Government) get the answer first then they are out of business. It's as simple as that!
Secondly, "...adequate for the purpose"?? What purpose? The purpose of deflecting criticism or buying good PR? Maybe they think the purpose is to buy them favour with the Government so that they will be protected from actually having to do anything?
Either way, I think this demonstrates their complete lack of understanding of this issue. Irrespective of how it started, a new movement has started at both national and international levels of politics which will eventually change the way the we use energy forever. One day (and sooner than we think) we will all have solar cells on our roofs, buildings will be self-sufficient, products and materials will be designed properly and will actually break down rather than just becoming landfill.
It will be this way because although the human race is incapable of changing its wasteful ways, it is more than capable of developing goods and services that mean we don't have to think about it.
And that is where the problem with this comment lies; they still think dealing with climate change is about giving money, buy off-sets or writing sustainability reports. It's not, its about developing new and better products and services: ironically, those companies that get to this first will make a CRAP load of money doing it.
Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts
Thursday, April 17, 2008
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
An introduction
I find sustainability fascinating. There are so many people out there running around telling me that our whole world is on the verge of collapse and that we should be doing everything from implementing emissions trading schemes to preventing the establishment of any new coal mines to save the planet.
What I find most amazing is that while there are so many things that help people 'be green', realistically, very few people do much that actually makes a significant difference. While turning off lights and off-setting our carbon emissions may make us feel good, they don't really change the fact that the majority of the emissions are economic emissions that exist because we live such a high standard of life.
And this is where the irony exists; any action we take to tackle climate change will actually reduce our standard of living. Now I don't subscribe to the economic ruin argument of one 'great' Australian because the simple act of developing solutions will provide a new means of economic activity to replace those we lose, however, things like emissions trading schemes or stopping new coals mines at this current stage do have the impact of increasing the costs of the current lifestyles we all lead.
Perhaps this is a good thing because people are buying more things than ever (just look at our constant economic growth figures for proof) and don't look like stopping this trend just because they are now concerned about climate change. If they were really concerned, they may realise that consumption is actually as much of the problem as anything else. Accordingly, they might choose to stop buying many of the products they current enjoy, even though this probably wont change the situation much either, because there will always be someone else just around the corner to buy it instead of them... and around the corner in this case, might just be someone overseas.
And this is where it all gets tricky; if we do implement measures such as an emissions trading scheme, we actually run the risk of 'exporting' the problem. Australia has some of the highest economic, environmental and social regulations in the developed world. Any good made in Australia probably damages the environment less than some goods made elsewhere, however, if we don't manage the climate change transition appropriately, our companies may just stop making goods in Australia because it is too expensive. Instead they will go overseas, where costs are less, regulations are less, and unfortunately, environmental damage is higher...
and if that happens, how have we created a positive for the global environment by implementing tough new measures to prevent climate change in Australia? Isn't this even more ironic when we consider that our contribution to the global problem is less than 2 percent? Wouldn't it be better if we could encourage more development of goods in Australia, and complement this development by massive investment in R&D to make those goods more sustainable?
What I find most amazing is that while there are so many things that help people 'be green', realistically, very few people do much that actually makes a significant difference. While turning off lights and off-setting our carbon emissions may make us feel good, they don't really change the fact that the majority of the emissions are economic emissions that exist because we live such a high standard of life.
And this is where the irony exists; any action we take to tackle climate change will actually reduce our standard of living. Now I don't subscribe to the economic ruin argument of one 'great' Australian because the simple act of developing solutions will provide a new means of economic activity to replace those we lose, however, things like emissions trading schemes or stopping new coals mines at this current stage do have the impact of increasing the costs of the current lifestyles we all lead.
Perhaps this is a good thing because people are buying more things than ever (just look at our constant economic growth figures for proof) and don't look like stopping this trend just because they are now concerned about climate change. If they were really concerned, they may realise that consumption is actually as much of the problem as anything else. Accordingly, they might choose to stop buying many of the products they current enjoy, even though this probably wont change the situation much either, because there will always be someone else just around the corner to buy it instead of them... and around the corner in this case, might just be someone overseas.
And this is where it all gets tricky; if we do implement measures such as an emissions trading scheme, we actually run the risk of 'exporting' the problem. Australia has some of the highest economic, environmental and social regulations in the developed world. Any good made in Australia probably damages the environment less than some goods made elsewhere, however, if we don't manage the climate change transition appropriately, our companies may just stop making goods in Australia because it is too expensive. Instead they will go overseas, where costs are less, regulations are less, and unfortunately, environmental damage is higher...
and if that happens, how have we created a positive for the global environment by implementing tough new measures to prevent climate change in Australia? Isn't this even more ironic when we consider that our contribution to the global problem is less than 2 percent? Wouldn't it be better if we could encourage more development of goods in Australia, and complement this development by massive investment in R&D to make those goods more sustainable?
Labels:
Australia,
climate change,
coal,
emissions trading,
exporting,
sustainability
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)