Showing posts with label demand and supply. Show all posts
Showing posts with label demand and supply. Show all posts

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Does greater density create greater sustainability outcomes?

To the outsider (and dare I say, for the insider), most urban planning pivots around the central assumption that greater density creates greater sustainability outcomes. Even without having any urban planning background, this assumption does intuitively make sense because with density you can minimise the amount of land cleared for housing, roads and infrastructure, and furthermore, get greater economies of scale for these and other investments, particularly public transport. Despite this intuitively making sense, after attending a number of recent forums and conferences, I get the feeling that environmental reasons and not economies of scale are driving the push for greater density.

Interestingly, however, the emphasis may be one-sided because despite the numerous planning guides limiting land release and promoting density, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) “… current homes (have) more bedrooms on average than homes ten years ago. At the same time, households are getting smaller on average with decreasing proportions of couple families with children and increasing couple only and lone person households.”

Other data doesn’t necessarily support the density assumption either. According to research conducted by the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF) in conjunction with the University of NSW, suburbs that typically have a higher density of population are actually less sustainable than those suburbs on the fringes of cities. According to Australia’s Consumption Atlas report, “…on average, single-person and small households have greater environmental impacts than larger households… (suburbs) with higher average household size also tend to have markedly lower levels of greenhouse gas pollution per capita, and smaller but still clearly lower levels of water use per capita.” ACF proposes that this is the case because wealth is higher in the inner suburbs and by extension, consumption is also higher. The primary argument of the ACF is that consumption is the key sustainability metric rather than location.

So where does the assumption that greater density produces greater sustainability outcomes emerge from? Especially if we look at some of perverse implications that urban growth boundaries have created.

Restricting land supply on the urban fringes of cities has created the situation where demand is massively outstripping supply. When combined with a prolonged period of economic growth that has provided the type of certainty individuals look for before making significant housing decisions, we now see people making decisions to have children or upgrade their homes (building their castles!). These individuals are then competing for the limited supply of land and what is interesting is that whereas once there may have been a greater sense of caution, currently we are seeing these competing individuals and families taking on greater mortgages and other debt because economic conditions are so good.

This is dangerous territory because while we may have environmental sustainability by virtue of reducing the amount of land cleared for housing, it is arguably at the cost of economic, and in particular social, sustainability outcomes. And while I agree that we should never understate the interconnected nature of the environmental system we live in, it seems that our current planning assumptions are not providing sustainable outcomes.

At the end of the day I think sustainability is a product of design because as the ACF’s research pointed out, the higher environmental impact caused by higher density suburbs is a product of consumption rather than location. If the products being consumed were designed better so that they used less electricity and water, and produced less waste, and likewise if fringes were better designed to take advantage of solar-passive design, used smarter materials (like brick!), and overall made less of an impact, then urban planning and environmental management would require a fundamentally different set of assumptions.

Because unfortunately I think that planners have occasionally lost touch with the very reason they exist, just as environmentalists have forgotten that individuals do have aspirations that are greater than their concern for the environment, and equally as business has forgotten that if there is no stable environment, then they will constantly lose money because of ‘acts of nature’ such as drought, flood, hail, etc etc.

Which brings us back to the question; does density create greater sustainability outcomes? Ironically, I think the planners had it partly right by imposing certain restrictions on developers. These restrictions, in the forms of land releases, environmental impact statements, infrastructure development etc have seen the rise of master planned estates that actually emphasis the benefits of good design. Things like recycled water, renewable power generation, tree planting, river and land regeneration, public transport, schools, and perhaps most importantly, partnerships with local businesses (to ensure jobs and services exist so the community can be self-sufficient) have become increasingly sophisticated and common.

So let’s not throw the baby out with the bath water; perhaps our best bet is to go to these developers and ask them questions about how they could do more of the good things they do, and likewise, what regulations should be in place to stop the ‘cowboys’ giving an entire industry a bad reputation! Because I think its fair assumption that leading developers would like anything which lifted their reputation in the community!

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Emissions trading as a mechaism to do something about climate change.

I attended the Sydney Public Forum being held in conjunction with the Labor party initiated Garnaut Climate Change Review today and took away some very interesting points which I am not sure were the actual intention of the day. Having said that, however, the Garnaut Review has been set up to identify the real issues of climate change for Australia, so any and all points should be considered relevant to the outcome which is Professor Ross Garnaut's final report due in mid-2008.

Basically, the key message I took away from the session was the difference between carbon abatement and carbon trading. Although putting a price on carbon and setting up a market to trade carbon as a commodity should theoretically lead to carbon abatement in the economy, there is no guarantee that this will happen. Further to this, I learned that it is possible that the cost of carbon abatement (most probably defined as improving energy efficiency and investing in alternative technologies) may actually be 7 to 8 times cheaper than the cost of carbon trading!

That's huge... and it does beg the question as to why trading schemes have been identified as a key component in overcoming the climate change challenge... especially by environmentalists who would probably quake if they understood the full breadth of what markets actually create. (And please don't take that as a swing at environmentalists... I am just trying to highlight how climate change is never going to be an environmental issue again!).

To try and answer the question as to why trading has been proposed it is probably best to think about this in terms of economics 101: what is carbon? It's a negative externality of production. A trading scheme aims to place a price on carbon to internalise this cost. Why are we using a market mechanism? Because this lets the forces of demand and supply set the appropriate price of carbon. If a trading scheme wasn't used, it would (most probably) be left to government to set the price in the form of a tax.

So while a tax would be cheaper for the economy in theory (ie no need to auction permits, have bodies set up to ensure compliance, use trading houses or brokers to sell and buy carbon permits, or hire lawyers to create complicated rules regarding what constitutes a carbon off-set), if the price was set too high, there would be unnecessary burden on the economy, and conversely, if the price was set to low, there would be no real incentive to take action.

Because of this and because ultimately no one like taxes, a carbon trading scheme is now the quasi bi-partisan policy in Australia. What is interesting about this is that there is no bi-partisan support for the fundamental tool of controlling a carbon market... emission targets.

At the end of the day, regardless of what the target is, for the market to operate successfully (and many of the speakers outlined what would make the market successful today... see below*) targets are needed because they set the supply. Without the supply there can be no real demand and without demand or supply, according to economics 101, there can be no market. Furthermore without targets, business (regardless of their sector or structure) does not have the certainty to invest in carbon abatement which, when all is said and done, is the main goal of any climate change action.


*According to one speaker the requirements for a successful carbon market are
  • certainty
  • breadth and depth
  • mature and large enough to encourage speculators
  • long-term
  • not dependent on a specific exchanges (ie the transaction will occur where is makes most rational sense).